Subtlety is over-rated.

Subtlety is over-rated.

https://twitter.com/Judd_of_Kryos/status/1482884960574922754
Your #DnD players are journeying to a new town and something is amiss. 👀 What are some subtle ways to hint to your players that something is wrong here?
Kids run up to the party cleric and/or paladin and all if their gods are going to destroy the devils that the mayor has summoned to consolidate their power. #subtle #DnD
Spears Subject Divider Image
From: https://www.clevelandart.org/art/1922.26.a

Most of the time I’d rather get my players into the mix with information at hand so they can make interesting, informed and meaningful decisions. There will still be room for surprises but in my experience, when I find myself actively hiding something from the players it is often a mistake.

Uncovering secret lore or figuring out a complicated situation can be fun. I’m just saying, keep careful track of how hard you are working to keep secrets or keep information from the players. Character decisions are far more interesting when they have more information.

Even when players don’t know things, I don’t think of it as hiding it from them or being subtle. I think of it as controlling pacing by unspooling the hidden at the pace of their discovery, especially if they are after the information and are taking smart angles to find it.

https://twitter.com/Judd_of_Kryos/status/1482886474534170626
More subtlety? OK Statues of saints crying blood. The Screaming Tree is at it again, they say. Everyone who has killed can see and talk to the ghosts of those they have slain. Everyone in town is trying to get the merchant’s son out of the mirror he accidentally walked into.

These designs and more in my Threadless shop – t-shirts of all kinds, mugs, stickers and even shower curtains…

Blog of Judd Karlman from Daydreaming about Dragons

D&Dish: Questions to ask players about their character’s Strength, Dexterity, Constitution, Intelligence, Wisdom and Charisma

Asking good questions is such a big part of being a good librarian that it was a shock when Apocalypse World first made me really think about questions as a tool at the table. Of course gamers asked each other questions before Apocalypse World; I’m not saying the Bakers invented questions or the question mark. But naming the tools in one’s toolbox makes it easier to reach for said tool and makes it easier to discuss how to use them well.

The questions here go back and forth between questions for high stats and questions for low stats. They can easily be changed a bit for the middle of the road results.

Below are the pretty versions with world bubbles and character sheets but below that is just the text.


12345

DnD Sheet Questions


Strength

Were you born strong or did you work hard to become strong?

 

What is/was the worst part about not being the strongest?

 

What feat of strength have you always wanted to accomplish?

 

How did you survive without physical strength?

 

When you locked up with the strongest person you’ve ever wrestled, what happened that made you realize they were stronger than you?

 

Dexterity

When did you realize you were faster/more graceful than everyone around you?

 

What is your worst nightmare about being clumsy?

 

What feat of grace have you always wanted to accomplish?

 

What did you almost drop?

 

Which monster was the children’s game you were so great at named after?

 

Constitution

What did being hale and healthy allow you to accomplish?

 

What was your haven during your sickest days?

 

What did you survive because you are so durable and healthy?

 

When were you most sick and who took care of you?

 

What did you attribute your great health to? Ancestors? Deities? The crystal clear water in the streams where you grew up?

 

Intelligence

When did you first realize you were the smartest person you knew?

 

How did you deal with the written word being so difficult for you?

 

What was the first problem you solved with your intellect?

 

How do you react to being called dumb?

 

What was the first problem you could not think your way out of?

 

Wisdom

What did you realize about the adults around you at a young age because of your incredible perception?

 

What problem in your community did you not see because of your lack of wisdom?

 

When did you first give wise advice to a friend and how did their problem find resolution?

 

What personal shortcoming did you fail to see until it was too late and damaged your life?

 

Which prayer has the most personal meaning for you?

 

Charisma

Who were some of the first people you remember charming?

 

How do you recover from bad first impressions?

 

When was the first time you realized the power you wielded in front of a large audience?

 

Who did your lack of charm and social grace push away that you really regret?

 

What was the best performance of your life so far?